Comments about Johnston & Murphy XC4 Cardell Saddle Oxfords:
This is just a cheap shoe. I have worn JM for a long time - and I cannot believe this is their shoe. It looks cheap, has a thin sole that looks like molded plastic, and is uncomfortable. I would love to ship it back. When you slip your foot into the shoe, the lace opening spreads so wide, it makes it look cheap (and I do not have a wide foot). I have two pairs (JM) in a similar style, and the difference in quality is astounding. I would give this shoe a zero if I could.