Click Image To Zoom
REVIEW SNAPSHOT®by PowerReviews
(based on 34 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Feels full size too small
Feels half size too small
Feels true to size
100% (12 reviews)
Feels half size too big
Feels full size too big
Feels too narrow
Feels true to width
100% (12 reviews)
Feels too wide
Most Liked Positive Review
My new favorite bootie!
Great looking boot. I purchased the putty color in a 6.5. I normally wear a size 7 in boots but it was too big. I have enough room for a thin sock. Super...Read complete review
Great looking boot. I purchased the putty color in a 6.5. I normally wear a size 7 in boots but it was too big. I have enough room for a thin sock. Super cute with leggings or skinny jeans. I have not had a chance to wear them for an extended period of time but so far seems comfortable. The only negative thing I have to say is I am worried the suede wont hold up. I have already water proofed them so hope that helps. I think I will likely purchase these again in the black color.
Most Liked Negative Review
I really want to love these but will likely send them back. I wear an 11N to an 11M and the petty bootie was fine in length and width across front of foot, but...Read complete review
I really want to love these but will likely send them back. I wear an 11N to an 11M and the petty bootie was fine in length and width across front of foot, but very loose over instep.
After wearing these for an hour, the bones on bottom outside edges of my feet hurt so much I was limping. Soles are very hard. Construction looks cheap and you can see where top is glued to heel it doesnt line up right.
These look huge on, even though I wear a size 11 and am used to large shoes. I have a pair of similar Erich Michael booties, also size 11, and they look 3 sizes smaller on my foot than the putty petty.
As others have said, the putty is more of a light grey in person which is what I prefer.
All that said, they are still adorable and I may try padded insoles before returning. Very disappointing.
Reviewed by 34 customers
Im in love.
I would recommend this bootie
Break them in
I would purchase in other colors!
I would definitely buy this shoe again. Wish they also came
Sad in SC
Great leather bootie for average size wearers
Comments about Sam Edelman Petty Booties:
Work, casual, any time. Love this bootie. Quality product. Perfect heal with zip for great fit. The sizing was a disappointment. I normally wear an 8W with perfect fit. This bootie is narrow across the bunion section making my feet hurt after a short while. If it came in an 8WW, I believe the fit would have been comfortable. I recommend for narrow wearers. The 8W fit more like an 8 medium. LOVE IT otherwise. Will try to stretch before I wear these again.