Added to Your Wish List
Processing ...
Continuing to Your Wish List
Processing ...
Processing ...
Processing ...

Processing in-store lookup...


Back to top

Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers

 
Share This Product With A Friend

Item #03368331

DMS: 0690  312   15-1095
 

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers
 
3.8

(based on 12 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (3)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (6)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (1)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (0)

80%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Pros

    Cons

      Best Uses

      • Wear to work (8)
      • Special occasions (4)
        • Fit:
        • Feels too small

           

          Feels true to size

           

          58% 

          (7 reviews)

          Feels too big

           
        • Waist:
        • Feels too small

           

          Feels true to size

           

          100% 

          (3 reviews)

          Feels too big

           
        • Length:
        • Feels too short

           

          Feels true to length

           

          100% 

          (4 reviews)

          Feels too long

           
        • Reviewer Profile:
        • Classic dresser (9), Casual dresser (3)
        • Comfort vs Style:
        • Comfort driven (8), Style driven (3)
        • Was this a gift?:
        • No (11)

      Most Liked Positive Review

       

      J&M Hayes Dress Loafers

      I have been wearing Cole Haan Pinch Tassles for twenty years but am unhappy with their decision to make them only with Nike Air soles at a $70 add; not worth it and ruins...Read complete review

      I have been wearing Cole Haan Pinch Tassles for twenty years but am unhappy with their decision to make them only with Nike Air soles at a $70 add; not worth it and ruins the fit of a loafer.
      Recently switched to the J&M Hayes Dress Loafer and find them to be equal in quality and style and a much more reasonable price.
      They do run slightly narrow so I wear a Wide (W) size in these in Black and Burgandy and they are very comfortable.
      I wish I could get the Mahogany in a Wide but it would seems that Dillard's does not carry them in stores or make them available online.

      VS

      Most Liked Negative Review

       

      Accurate

      Shoes too stiff-have not gotten them on yet-will try again-nothing flexable about them-stiff & hard when trying to bend.

      Shoes too stiff-have not gotten them on yet-will try again-nothing flexable about them-stiff & hard when trying to bend.

      Reviewed by 12 customers

      Sort by

      Displaying reviews 1-10

      Back to top

      Previous | Next »

       
      5.0

      Very Nice Shoe

      By Toby

      from AR

      About Me Classic Dresser

      Verified Buyer

      Pros

      • Nice Color
      • Nice Fabric

      Cons

        Best Uses

        • Wear To Work

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

        The shoes are tight at first; however, that gives them the opportunity to form to your foot. Once they are broken in, they fit beautifully.

        • Fit:
        • Feels true to size
        • Comfort vs Style:
        • Comfort Driven
        • Was this a gift?:
        • No

        Comment on this review

        (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

         
        4.0

        2nd time purchase, same shoe, same store

        By Slicker

        from Paducah, Ky

        About Me Classic Dresser

        Verified Buyer

        Pros

          Cons

            Best Uses

            • Special Occasions
            • Wear To Work

            Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

            This is my 2nd pair, same shoes, also purchased from Dillards. Had 1st pair resoled once and re-heeled 2 or 3 times in 3-4 yrs I owned/wore them.
            Obviously I like them. Thank you.

            • Fit:
            • Feels true to size
            • Comfort vs Style:
            • Style Driven
            • Was this a gift?:
            • No

            Comment on this review

            (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

             
            5.0

            Die-Hard Customer

            By Shawno

            from St. Louis MO

            About Me Classic Dresser

            See all my reviews

            Verified Buyer

            Pros

              Cons

                Best Uses

                • Special Occasions
                • Wear To Work

                Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                I bought two pairs of these. One black and one burgundy. The burgundy pair was slightly damaged. I returned to them to the store and returned them with no hassle. The store I went to did not have the same size so they will be replaced in time. Refund was seamless. Retail Sales Guy was cool. So of course Dillard's is where I go for these shoes.

                • Fit:
                • Feels true to size
                • Comfort vs Style:
                • Style Driven
                • Was this a gift?:
                • No

                Comment on this review

                (1 of 3 customers found this review helpful)

                 
                2.0

                too small

                By JG

                from Weatherford, tx

                About Me Classic Dresser

                Verified Buyer

                Pros

                • RUNS SMALL

                Cons

                  Best Uses

                    Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                    This style runs small compared to other J&M shoes. Will have to return. The ones I have on are 9's and I can't even begin to get the new ones on.

                    • Fit:
                    • Feels too small
                    • Comfort vs Style:
                    • Comfort Driven
                    • Was this a gift?:
                    • No

                    Comment on this review

                    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

                     
                    4.0

                    Good Durable Dress Shoe

                    By Shawno

                    from St. Louis MO

                    About Me Casual Dresser

                    See all my reviews

                    Pros

                    • Good value

                    Cons

                      Best Uses

                      • Date Night/Night Out
                      • Special Occasions
                      • Wear To Work

                      Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                      I wore Cole Haan for quite along time. There was at time I gave J & M a shot. To my surprise the JM's last nearly twice as long. They are basically the same shoe. However Johnston Murphy is my first choice. Also have a few pairs of Oxfords. Same deal. Super value, style and durability..

                      • Fit:
                      • Feels true to size
                      • Waist:
                      • Feels true to size
                      • Length:
                      • Feels true to length
                      • Comfort vs Style:
                      • Style Driven
                      • Was this a gift?:
                      • No

                      Comment on this review

                      (4 of 5 customers found this review helpful)

                       
                      4.0

                      J&M Hayes Dress Loafers

                      By Mark C

                      from Plano, TX

                      About Me Classic Dresser

                      Pros

                      • Classic style

                      Cons

                      • No W Width In Mahogany

                      Best Uses

                      • Wear To Work

                      Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                      I have been wearing Cole Haan Pinch Tassles for twenty years but am unhappy with their decision to make them only with Nike Air soles at a $70 add; not worth it and ruins the fit of a loafer.
                      Recently switched to the J&M Hayes Dress Loafer and find them to be equal in quality and style and a much more reasonable price.
                      They do run slightly narrow so I wear a Wide (W) size in these in Black and Burgandy and they are very comfortable.
                      I wish I could get the Mahogany in a Wide but it would seems that Dillard's does not carry them in stores or make them available online.

                      • Fit:
                      • Feels too small
                      • Was this a gift?:
                      • No

                      Comment on this review

                      (2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)

                       
                      4.0

                      Good Craftsmanship

                      By Mike W

                      from Fort Myers, FL

                      About Me Classic Dresser

                      Verified Buyer

                      Pros

                        Cons

                          Best Uses

                          • Casual Wear
                          • Special Occasions
                          • Wear To Work

                          Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                          I have discontinued purchasing Bass shoes due to their poor quality and disregard for customer satisfaction. I have found that Johnston & Murphy have the styling and quality in many of their shoes that I had previously admired in Bass shoes for +40 years. My only regret is that I wear a 7.5 D or M which is often difficult to find at Dillards in the styles I like. I had to purchase an 8M which is not my ideal fit. It would be very nice if they were made in the USA.

                          • Fit:
                          • Feels too big
                          • Comfort vs Style:
                          • Comfort Driven
                          • Was this a gift?:
                          • No

                          Comment on this review

                          (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

                           
                          5.0

                          Classic and Perfect

                          By Mskembo

                          from Dallas, TX

                          About Me Casual Dresser

                          Verified Reviewer

                          Pros

                          • Easy Break In
                          • Good quality

                          Cons

                            Best Uses

                            • Date Night/Night Out
                            • Wear To Work

                            Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                            My wife bought me these for Christmas, and I've been wearing them for the past few days to work. They were a little stiff the first day, but after that they feel like they were meant to be on my feet.

                            I've owned several pairs of J&M shoes over th years, and she looked at my current J&M wingtips to get my size (11 1/2) the salesman told her to try a half size smaller, which she did, and they fit perfect.

                            One thing that I've noticed for years is that my foot is very brand dependent on sizing. I wear a 12 1/2 in Nikes, and down as far as 10 1/2 in Clark's. With those being the outliers, I believe 11-11 1/2 is about right for my shoe size.

                            • Fit:
                            • Feels true to size
                            • Waist:
                            • Feels true to size
                            • Length:
                            • Feels true to length
                            • Comfort vs Style:
                            • Comfort Driven
                            • Was this a gift?:
                            • Yes

                            Comment on this review

                            (0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

                             
                            4.0

                            Comfortable

                            By RK

                            from Tampa, Florida

                            About Me Classic Dresser

                            Pros

                              Cons

                                Best Uses

                                  Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                                  Wish they had a rubber (non slip) insert in the sole of the shoe.

                                  • Fit:
                                  • Feels true to size
                                  • Comfort vs Style:
                                  • Comfort Driven
                                  • Was this a gift?:
                                  • No

                                  Comment on this review

                                  (4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)

                                   
                                  4.0

                                  Getting ready to buy another pair

                                  By Guy

                                  from Mesa, AZ

                                  About Me Classic Dresser

                                  Pros

                                    Cons

                                      Best Uses

                                        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Dress Loafers:

                                        The first pair lasted three years. I've had another pair for two years. Had them re-heeled and later half soled. Getting ready to buy another pair because I've worn out the insoles. They still shine well and look good.

                                        • Fit:
                                        • Feels true to size
                                        • Waist:
                                        • Feels true to size
                                        • Length:
                                        • Feels true to length
                                        • Comfort vs Style:
                                        • Comfort Driven
                                        • Was this a gift?:
                                        • No

                                        Comment on this review

                                        Displaying reviews 1-10

                                        Back to top

                                        Previous | Next »