CLOSE

Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops

Item #04883738

$46.00Extended Sizes
×
Full size zoom image
Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Black - Image 1 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Black - Image 2 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Black - Image 3 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Black - Image 4 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Brown - Image 1 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Brown - Image 2 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Brown - Image 3 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
  • Color:Brown - Image 4 - Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops

    Shop the collection

      Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops

      REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

      by PowerReviews
      Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops
       
      4.5

      (based on 57 reviews)

      Ratings Distribution

      • 5 Stars

         

        (41)

      • 4 Stars

         

        (7)

      • 3 Stars

         

        (4)

      • 2 Stars

         

        (4)

      • 1 Stars

         

        (1)

      89%

      of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

      Pros

      • Comfortable (22)
      • Arch support (16)
      • Stylish (16)
      • Lightweight (15)
      • Durable (9)

      Cons

      No Cons

      Best Uses

      • Casual wear (19)
      • Outdoors (11)
      • Travel (11)
      • At the beach (9)
      • Going out (8)
        • Sizing:
        • Feels full size too small

           

          Feels half size too small

           

          Feels true to size

           

          78% 

          (18 reviews)

          Feels half size too big

           

          Feels full size too big

           
        • Width:
        • Feels too narrow

           

          Feels true to width

           

          86% 

          (18 reviews)

          Feels too wide

           
        • Reviewer Profile:
        • Casual dresser (17), Stylish (8), Conservative (5), Trendy style (5)
        • Was this a gift?:
        • No (7)

      Most Liked Positive Review

       

      Nice and comfy with a few caveats...

      Have been wanting to replace another Reef sandal that is actually higher than this one with slightly wider straps. Those sandals had replaced an even older pair of reef platform sandals with wide straps...Read complete review

      Have been wanting to replace another Reef sandal that is actually higher than this one with slightly wider straps. Those sandals had replaced an even older pair of reef platform sandals with wide straps (think they were braided) that I wore for years until one strap failed in Maui in 2009. So, basically, I keep my Reefs for years. I have another Butter that is one height and has a leather footbed. If I put them on right after getting out of the ocean or pool, they would be slippery and a trip/fall hazard. These are not like those. They have a bit of a higher heel and about a 1" platform, which I really like. The heel makes them look a little dressier maybe. I'm also 5'6" and enjoy gaining a little height from them. The footbed is super cushy, but with support. There is actually arch support in these - its a bit high and took some getting used to, but I have a decent arch and it feels good to me now. Like super comfy now. I could see these not working for someone with lower/flat arches, though. The toe post is in the right place for me and my toes don't protrude out beyond the front of the sandal when walking (I do have somewhat long toes). The one thing is that my feet get black on the bottom from wearing these. They're still new, so I'm hoping that will go away with time and use (fingers crossed). Reef make great sandals, and as long as they keep making thicker/platform sandals I'll likely keep buying them. If, however, those taller, 2.5" heel, 1" platforms with wide braided straps come back (in black) then I'll be buying 20 pairs and wearing them to my grave. 5 stars for cute/comfort, 1 star off for turning my feet black.

      VS

      Most Liked Negative Review

       

      Almost perfect

      I hesitated to order these online because I tend to have such bad luck with shoes that seem really comfortable at first or without trying them on. When I received these and first put...Read complete review

      I hesitated to order these online because I tend to have such bad luck with shoes that seem really comfortable at first or without trying them on. When I received these and first put them on, they were REALLY comfortable and it seemed like I wouldn't have any problems with them, but after I walked a few blocks in them one day, the straps started rubbing skin off the inside sides of my feet. The insides of the straps are covered with fabric, but there's a tiny edge of the leather strap that's not covered, and I think that's what's rubbing.

      Since I didn't find this out until I'd worn them a bit, I couldn't return them. I think it'll get better as I develop calluses, but it was really annoying to find that out the hard way.

      Reviewed by 57 customers

      Displaying reviews 1-10

      Back to top

      Previous | Next »

       
      5.0

      I would buy these again for my wife.

      By 

      from undisclosed

      Verified Buyer

      Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

      Lovely

       
      5.0

      Love, love, love Reef Butter Cushion

      By 

      from Scottsdale, AZ

      About Me Casual

      Pros

      • Comfortable

      Cons

        Best Uses

        • At The Beach
        • Casual Wear

        Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

        I wear these all day every day—cute and comfortable!
        Reef—PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE bring these back in black! I bought two pairs last year and now you don't make them anymore. :(
        Also, ages ago you used to make them in other colors and that would be great too!

        • Sizing:
        • Feels true to size
        • Width:
        • Feels true to width
         
        1.0

        Sadden I had to returned.

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

        I purchased four pairs of these reef cushion flip flops back in 2000. Ones in size 10s and the others in size 11s. I still have the size 11s . Oh, in black and brown colors. I love these flip flops, but the new ones I purchased was too small and hard on my feet. I am sadden I can't keep the new ones.

        P.S. I know they are a hot mess, but I love them.

         
        5.0

        I highly recommend these

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

        Love, love, love my Reef's for my feet's. Best flip flops EVER.....soo comfortable. I wear them year round.

         
        5.0

        Love these sandals

        By 

        from Boston, MA

        Pros

        • Comfortable
        • Good Arch Support
        • Stylish

        Cons

          Best Uses

          • Casual Wear
          • Travel

          Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

          I love every pair of Reef sandals that I have bought. I have been buying them for the past 15 or so years.
          I read a review, that said, "the strap rubbed on the edge where it wasn't covered". I take a fine nail file and "lightly" rub the edge with the edge of the file and that rounds and softens the material.

          • Sizing:
          • Feels true to size
          • Width:
          • Feels true to width
           
          5.0

          The most comfortable sandal or flip flop

          By 

          from New Milford,CT

          About Me Casual, Stylish

          Pros

          • Comfortable
          • Durable
          • Good Arch Support
          • Lightweight
          • Stylish

          Cons

            Best Uses

            • At The Beach
            • Casual Wear
            • Outdoors
            • Travel

            Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

            I bought a pair about 10 yrs ago and wore them out. I bought a pair last summer and lived in them this summer and as long as its warm enough to wear them. I have had numerous back surgeries and find it hard finding a shoe that doesn't cause my pain to get worse. With the arch support they are better than many shoes I've worn. I have less pain wearing them and wore my sneakers and I have orthotics in and I had more pain wearing them. I hate summer but I'm bummed that I have to give them up when it's too cold! Buying another pair.

             
            5.0

            Butter is the best!

            By 

            from undisclosed

            Verified Buyer

            Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

            So excited the "butter" is back! Hands down the best women's flip flop ever!!!

             
            5.0

            Reef Cushion is the perfect walking Flip Flop

            By 

            from undisclosed

            Verified Buyer

            Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

            The Reef Cushion Butter fit like they were made for me! These are top of the line flip flops that needed no breaking in. They were perfection from the moment I slipped them on. They look great on and give me a little extra height, which is great. I walk all over the place and they have been so easy and comfortable to walk in. These flip flops are coming with me to Thailand . Thanks Reef!

             
            5.0

            Love it- Comfort, Style and Lift!

            By 

            from undisclosed

            Verified Buyer

            Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

            Great heights, comfort and style. I am short and love the lift, while still not feeling like I am wearing "high heels". No pain with these! Love the look and comfort and extra height. Go REEF! Great stuff, glad I found you! This will be my 3rd pair of REEF sandals.

             
            5.0

            Best of the Best Flip-Flops

            By 

            from undisclosed

            Verified Buyer

            Comments about Reef Butter Vegan Leather Flip Flops:

            I wear mine everywhere. Very comfortable, and they stay on your feet. The thong-strap doesn't lose elasticity so it hugs your foot. Other flip-flops I have lose that elasticity and start sliding off my feet in a very short time. I am going to buy another pair to throw in my pre-packed luggage (travel for work). They have great support too. They may feel a bit different at first, but after a day of walking in them, you'll love them. Just wish they came in different colors/styles. The platform gives a bit of height without being outrageous or losing your balance. I am a 6-6.5 and bought the 7. I can wear both the 6 and 7. The 6 hits my heel right at the end of the sandal, and the 7 gives me about 1/2 inch +/- at the end of the sandal. Also, be aware that if you don't wear t-strap, thong, or flip-flop sandals on a continual basis, the strap between the toe may rub to a blister. This happens whenever I get a new pair of shoes/sandals so it's not a deal-breaker for me. I just need to be aware of the "break-in" spots and use preventative measures like blister bandages (which are amazing). Enjoy your new REEFs...you'll wear them everywhere. (Sweepstakes)

            Displaying reviews 1-10

            Back to top

            Previous | Next »