Skip navigation
CLOSE

Johnston & Murphy

Hayes Dress Penny Loafers

Item # 03368304

$99.99Extended Sizes
×
Full size zoom image
Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers
  • Color:Black - Image 1 - Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers
  • Color:Burgundy - Image 1 - Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers

    Shop the collection

        Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers

        REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

        by PowerReviews
        Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers
         
        3.8

        (based on 16 reviews)

        Ratings Distribution

        • 5 Stars

           

          (7)

        • 4 Stars

           

          (4)

        • 3 Stars

           

          (1)

        • 2 Stars

           

          (2)

        • 1 Stars

           

          (2)

        78%

        of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

        Pros

        • Classic design (4)
        • Comfortable (3)

        Cons

        No Cons

        Best Uses

        • Casual wear (6)
        • Business casual (4)
        • Date night (3)
        • Going out (3)
        • Work (3)
          • Sizing:
          • Feels full size too small

             

            Feels half size too small

             

            Feels true to size

             

            83% 

            (5 reviews)

            Feels half size too big

             

            Feels full size too big

             
          • Width:
          • Feels too narrow

             

            Feels true to width

             

            83% 

            (5 reviews)

            Feels too wide

             
          • Reviewer Profile:
          • Conservative (3), Stylish (3)

        Most Liked Positive Review

         

        Johnston & Murphy

        Super comfortable. Looks great with slacks or shorts.

        Super comfortable. Looks great with slacks or shorts.

        VS

        Most Liked Negative Review

         

        poor quality

        Shoes looked good. Wore for casual wear and with sport coat. First pair split right at bend in toes within five months ( I keep my shoes forever some older than my twenty something...Read complete review

        Shoes looked good. Wore for casual wear and with sport coat. First pair split right at bend in toes within five months ( I keep my shoes forever some older than my twenty something year old children) second pair split in less time. I rotate my shoes daily so they are only worn maybe twice a week. Shoe was not expensive but should have had a longer life. Dillard's exchanged the first pair.

        Reviewed by 16 customers

        Displaying reviews 1-10

        Back to top

        Previous | Next »

         
        1.0

        unsatisfactory shoes

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        The shoes squeak when I walk and they are not satisfactory. I tried to wear them thinking that it would go away, but the squeak did not stop. Instead. the noise got worse. I am returning them.

         
        5.0

        Great shoes.

        By 

        from Greeneville

        See all my reviews

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        I purchased two pairs of these shoes. Burgundy and black. They arrived sooner than I expected. Well made shoes, very stylish and very comfortable.

         
        5.0

        Great product

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        Fast

         
        5.0

        I would definately buy this shoe again.

        By 

        from Pearland, Tx

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        I bought these shoes about 2 years ago and I really like them. They are very comfortable and go well
        with slacks or jeans. I really like Johnston & Murphy shoes, they are well made.

        • Sizing:
        • Feels true to size
        • Width:
        • Feels true to width
         
        4.0

        Yes

        By 

        from undisclosed

        See all my reviews

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        Great shoe

         
        2.0

        No

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        Color was not as pictured. Very disappointed

         
        3.0

        Be careful before buying these shoes online...

        By 

        from undisclosed

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        The Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers are well constructed and is a seemingly quality product. However, the sizing may require more attention before purchasing. Recently, I visited and purchased the tassel loafer ( J&M- 10 1/2W ) from Dillard's; it was an excellent fit. So, my assumption was, I could buy the exact size online and be happy... wrong. I ordered the shoes; tried them, they were a little tight; wore them to allow for stretching of the leather, but could not get the width stretched. The sales associate couldn't help me because the shoe was not in stock at the store, not the warehouse. When I ordered the shoes, there were only two pairs left (online). The store didn't have my size or color to exchange. So, be weary before ordering this shoe online, the shoes actual sizes vary, compared to the marked size.

         
        5.0

        Awesome

        By 

        from Carbondale, IL 62901

        Verified Buyer

        Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

        Beautiful loafers

        (0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

         
        4.0

        I will buy fhis again

        By 

        from Boston Ma

        About Me Conservative

        Verified Buyer

        Pros

        • Classic Design

        Cons

          Best Uses

          • Business Casual
          • Casual Wear

          Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

          On time

          • Sizing:
          • Feels true to size
          • Width:
          • Feels true to width

          (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

           
          5.0

          Johnston and Murphy Lifelong Customer

          By 

          from Stilwell, Oklahoma

          About Me Comfort-oriented, High-end shopper, Stylish

          Pros

          • Breathes Well
          • Classic Design
          • Comfortable
          • Durable
          • Good Cushioning
          • Lightweight
          • Stable

          Cons

            Best Uses

            • Business Casual
            • Casual Wear
            • Date Night
            • Going Out
            • Work

            Comments about Johnston & Murphy Hayes Dress Penny Loafers:

            Wear daily, miles of walking. Shoes are very comfortable (once broken in) Feet don't get tired. Constructed very well and nicely balanced. Only issue was had to try 3 pairs to get a well matched pair for sizing. There was as much as 1/2 size difference on some. So I would recommend trying as many pairs as necessary to get them right. Well worth the extra time. They're your feet !!!!

            • Sizing:
            • Feels true to size
            • Width:
            • Feels true to width

            Displaying reviews 1-10

            Back to top

            Previous | Next »