Skip navigation
CLOSE

MAC

Kohl Power Eye Pencil

Item # 03181392

$18.00
×
Full size zoom image
MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil

    Shop the collection

        MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil

        REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

        by PowerReviews
        MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil
         
        4.1

        (based on 158 reviews)

        Ratings Distribution

        • 5 Stars

           

          (97)

        • 4 Stars

           

          (21)

        • 3 Stars

           

          (14)

        • 2 Stars

           

          (6)

        • 1 Stars

           

          (20)

        71%

        of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

        Pros

        No Pros

        Cons

        No Cons

        Best Uses

        No Best Uses
          • Product Benefits:
          • Bold color (95), Long wearing (84), Smudgeable (66), Creamy (27), Color true (24)

        Most Liked Positive Review

         

        Smudgeable Bold Color

        I wanted a kohl eye pencil that would work well for the waterline. Everyone talks about Smolder, but when I went to the MAC counter at my local department store, the SA suggested...Read complete review

        I wanted a kohl eye pencil that would work well for the waterline. Everyone talks about Smolder, but when I went to the MAC counter at my local department store, the SA suggested Feline. He showed me both pencils on his hand and I could see that Feline was the more intense black. That was all I needed to see. This is the most intense black color. It makes my green eyes stand out even more. It has great staying power in the waterline. I normally wear dark brown on upper and lower lids, but the SA showed me that if I applied Feline carefully and very close to my lash line, then it would work . For more longlasting wear, I put Carbon eyeshadow over it. It's nice to know that if I apply carefully, I can still use black on my upper and lower lashline at times for a more dramatic look. As a mature woman, I had pretty much given up on it, but now I know that it can look great if applied correctly. I am very happy with Feline. It's perfect for me.

        VS

        Most Liked Negative Review

         

        smug and transfer

        The consistency and glides on easily but this product is not for me. I have watery eyes and the liner stay about few minutes on my eyes and then starts transferring all over. It...Read complete review

        The consistency and glides on easily but this product is not for me. I have watery eyes and the liner stay about few minutes on my eyes and then starts transferring all over. It just doesn't stick to the skin. I have tried smolder and Teddy. Both colors have same issues. It just transfer like crazy on watery eyes. Since, smolder is every intense black shade. It makes it even worse to wear.
        Anyways a great product but not for everybody.

        Reviewed by 158 customers

        Displaying reviews 1-10

        Back to top

        Previous | Next »

         
        1.0

        Worse than some drugstore eyeliners!

        By 

        from US

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I got this eyeliner in Smoulder and Teddy bc I thought they would last me all day. While Teddy worked fine for me (smearing a little bit then staying), Smoulder was horrible! Not long after applying it it starts to smear and run like crazy! I can't believe I paid so much for an eyeliner only to have it smear. I've tried many drugstore eyeliners before this one. I would actually recommend Milani Stay put eyeliner (which I bought after my horrible Smoulder experience) before this product! Cheaper and it holds on for a few hours before smearing. Tarte eyeliners are also great!

        • Age:
        • 25-34
        • Product Benefits:
        • Blendable
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • maccosmetics.com
         
        5.0

        Fascinating!

        By 

        from Colorado, USA

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I bought this in the color fascinating (white) and I loved it! Unlike other white eye pencils that I own, this one actually does color without having to press too hard on my skin. This pencil does everything its description claims.

        • Product Benefits:
        • beautiful, Bold Color, Color true, Creamy, Long wearing
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • maccosmetics.com
         
        1.0

        MESSY, SMUDGES LIKE CRAZY

        By 

        from USA

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I don't even have watery eyes, but this smudged like crazy and lingered on my eyes even after vigorous washing. this will ruin your look. disappointed.

        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • maccosmetics.com

        (2 of 3 customers found this review helpful)

         
        1.0

        TERRIBLE! Smudges, Runs, Raccoon Eyes Immediately after appl

        By 

        from Boston, MA, USA

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        M.A.C. Eye Kohl Pencil in color Smolder: I never write reviews but this is SO BAD that I had to! I lined my upper lids (on top of eyelashes and underneath eyelashes on the tight line - I Did NOT line my lower water line). As soon as I blinked my eyes the product smeared down onto my water line and within a 1/2 hour both eyes were smudged and I had Raccoon eyes! Don't waste your money. TERRIBLE EYELINER! POOR QUALITY!

        • Product Benefits:
        • do not buy! don't waste ur money!

        (2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

         
        5.0

        The only eyeliner I've ever used, or will ever use!

        By 

        from Stamford, CT

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I am a beauty junkie and have tried countless eyeliners, but I always come back to this product. It is the only liner that works on my waterline without irritating my sensitive eyes, and allows control for as much or as little as I desire per application. It never breaks when sharpening, is long-wearing and bold. My go-to!

        • Product Benefits:
        • Bold Color, Color true, Long wearing
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • maccosmetics.com
         
        5.0

        Creamy

        By 

        from Brea, CA, USA

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        The struggle I have with almost every eyeliner is fading and smudging all the way down my undereyes. I have the color Smolder and I love this eyeliner because the color and it doesn't smudge like crazy. You definitely can smudge it when first apply it but just put a little bit of eyeshadow on afterwards and it stays on forever! I usually bring my eyeliner (to reapply one time during lunch) but find that if I forget to reapply it still looks pretty good at the end of the day.

        • Product Benefits:
        • Color true, Creamy, Long wearing
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • maccosmetics.com

        (2 of 4 customers found this review helpful)

         
        1.0

        Thoroughly disappointing

        By 

        from Kolkata

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        This product is extremely disappointing, and I urge you to think before buying. I purchased it in London and it is a waste of money. This product does not do whatever its description says. It does not line and define. Instead it smudges horribly. If you apply it on your inner line, very soon it will be all over and under your eyes, leaving you looking very untidy. Does not have a good finish. Neither is it long lasting. It is not required at all in your make up kit. Go for something useful, rather than this kohl which will be all over your face,rather than where it is supposed to be.

        • Product Benefits:
        • do not buy
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • MAC Store

        (1 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

         
        1.0

        NOT GOOD.

        By 

        from India

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I bought M.A.C EYE KOHL CRAYON KHOL, SMOLDER and it's not performed well because it's spreading while using.

        It's NOT WORTH TO BUY.

        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • MAC Store

        (0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

         
        1.0

        Leaves dark cercles

        By 

        from Bordeaux

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        I used this pencil to underline my waterline. One hour after I was badly surprised by dark cercles under my eyes. The product just went away leaving cerclies at my skin that I couldn't erase! I didn't have a special make up remover this day and even with remover it goes away hardly.

        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • MAC Store
         
        1.0

        What a mess

        By 

        from Newport Beach, CA, USA

        Comments about MAC Kohl Power Eye Pencil:

        This is usually what I say to my reflection after I have tried to use this product.

        • Product Benefits:
        • messy
        • Where did you purchase this product?:
        • MAC Store

        Displaying reviews 1-10

        Back to top

        Previous | Next »